September24
Whilst merrily taping away at my computer I noticed a headline about Lily Allen and piracy come up on the news feed thingy.. so I clicked and ended up reading her blog about music piracy.
The blog post got me riled enough to actually want to comment on it, but I discovered I couldn’t as I wasn’t her friend on myspace. I tried to add her as a friend but it seems she won’t accept requests from bands (which includes me it seems as I have a music profile!).
Anyway, I will vent here instead…
Firslty, Lily states that piracy is basically killing music, film, tv.. etc When this really isn’t the case. Piracy has been around for years (remember copying tapes?). There are hundreds of articles on the internet about this (check out some of the Guardian Tech blog podcasts, there was a special on it not so long ago which was very interesting), and many studies have shown that piracy really isn’t harming sales. The problem is much wider and deeper, the major labels are having a hard time keeping up with changing technology and have to adapt their business models a lot quicker if they’re going to survive.
Anyway, I’m really not going to get into the specifics, I shall continue..
The thing that really annoyed me about the post is Lily saying things like ‘it’s hard enough trying to get a job at the moment’; as if she knows anything about trying to get a job or the hardship ‘normal’ people are facing. ‘I don’t care so much about the high-ups’ – Lets face it Lily, you ARE one of the high-ups! You’d be pretty gutted if they dropped you right? Much better to get rid of some interns than cut your royalties no?
She also makes a point that no new innovation in film or music is happening, while to a certain extent I agree with this I’d like to point out: firstly using Harry Potter 7 is a pretty bad example (the reason they made HP1-7 is because there are that many books… did you complain when JKR wrote the sequels?). Also, there is LOADS of innovation happening in both music and film, just search on MySpace (your favourite site Lily.. remember?) or YouTube. Undergroung filmmaking and musicmaking is going on everywhere and people are putting out their music and videos for free for people to watch online, and some of it gets very popular. What Lily is trying to say is that the mainstream market (where the money is.. where SHE is) is being saturated by mass-marketed crap.
I do not disagree.
But again, I think the problem there is the Major Labels and film companies themselves who put this out, not the lack of talent. I love the way she says ‘piracy is just playing into the hands of the corporations.’ Lily.. you ARE the corporations.. you’re on EMI!!
Ok Lily.. don’t get me wrong, if you’re reading this (and you’ve read this far.. wow.. thanks!) I do agree that piracy might not be the best thing. My band only just broke even on physical sales last year, we run our own label and have very close control over finances etc. I checked the number of times the album had been download on mininova.org and if every person that downloaded the album had bought one at a show (2030 downloads from that site.. who knows how many elsewhere) we’d have been able to give up our dayjobs.
But I really don’t hold it against people.. as an artist I want people to hear my music. I don’t have the money for a major ad campaign or to get airplay on Radio 1 so if piracy means lots of people can listen to what I do then so be it. It’s all very well saying down with piracy when you’re sitting on a fat major label payroll and being pushed by big-budget marketting, but when you’re an underground artist trying to get heard then you need all the help you can get.
I think the alternative that will please everyone are systems like spotify or last.fm especially now that you can get them on mobile devices.
If I like a band I’ll buy their CD, I’ll buy their Tshirt and I’ll come to their gigs. If I’m not that fussed I’ll stream them on spotify or download their album from somewhere (sorry Lily.. that includes yours). I wouldn’t have bothered buying it otherwise so really they’re not missing out.
Am I wrong? Probably… feel free to comment. Best one wins a prize.
Tweet This Post
Plurk This Post
Buzz This Post
Delicious
Digg This Post
Facebook
MySpace
Ping This Post
Reddit
Stumble This Post